Nobody knows for sure if the universe is fundamentally elegant, but we assume this sometimes in order to make scientific progress.

By 3 Sethrates on February 16, 2007

Embed Claim Make a related claim

Discussion (7)

http://sethrates.myopenid.com/

3 Sethrates who agreed, says

Fair enough; they're certainly different claims. I think too many people, physicists included, mix up the useful assumption of elegance with a belief in elegance. I prefer not to have an opinion on your question, which makes me wonder in retrospect why I voted. ;)

Make a related claim about 1 year ago (link)
http://sethrates.myopenid.com/

3 Sethrates who agreed, says

They should feel guilty. Every extra belief we bring with us when we do science undermines the work.

Make a related claim about 1 year ago (link)
http://kybernetikos.com/openid/

4 kybernetikos who hasn't voted, says

But some enable the work.

Make a related claim about 1 year ago (link)
http://slavetoreality.myopenid.com/

4 Nebula Man who disagreed, says

If elegance is experienced we must accept the fundamental workings of the universe allow this to be so. This is elegant itself, that refined to a point such a thing would occur.

Make a related claim about 1 year ago (link)
http://www.breathwork.be/

1 Geoffrey Smith who disagreed, says

In order to claim that something is not we must have experience of what it means for that thing to be what it is not and we must have experience of both the thing we are claiming it is not and what we are therefore claiming it to be.

Butterflies do better than this...

Make a related claim about 1 year ago (link)
http://digory.myopenid.com/

1 digory who disagreed, says

in the begining was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God ... through Him all things were made and without him was not anything made that was made ... for from Him, and through Him, and to Him are all things.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://digory.myopenid.com/

1 digory who disagreed, says

yes of course it does
it states that the universe is unified
with one simple unifying principle
(a principle far to simple and unified for humans ever to be able to fully grasp Him)

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
Sign in in to leave a comment.