If you picked a jyte user from a hat, it would likely be a male that drinks beer.

By 7 Kara needs a vacation on July 25, 2008

And he'd probably have felt prints on his face from being squished in there.

claim image
Embed Claim Make a related claim

Discussion (21)

http://logicaldog.myopenid.com/

4 Logical Dog who agreed, says

++ for the bunny bowtie and "felt prints"

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://claimid.com/dewe

6 DeWe who hasn't voted, says

It'd have to be a big hat for Xisth.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://claimid.com/dewe

6 DeWe who hasn't voted, says

He's a big chap.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://xisth.information.myopenid.com/

4 Comestibles J Coolio who hasn't voted, says

that's no lie. there's not a hat been made that can hold me.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://bananasfk.wordpress.com/

4 bananasfk.wordpress.com who agreed, says

I can bring a chicken

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://vynce.myopenid.com/

8 Vynce who agreed, says

otoh, this is also true of adult internet users in general.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://karalyg.myvidoop.com/

7 Kara needs a vacation who agreed, says

You think? I don't feel like more than 50% of internet users are men who also drink beer.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://darch.myopenid.com/

6 D'Archangel who agreed, says

I don't think they have to be in the majority for "likely" to apply. Nor even a plurality. It's enough that they be a significant fraction.

D'A

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://bananasfk.wordpress.com/

4 bananasfk.wordpress.com who agreed, says

party time !

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://karalyg.myvidoop.com/

7 Kara needs a vacation who agreed, says

hmm, in my mind likely is either greater than half or the largest available fraction.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://vynce.myopenid.com/

8 Vynce who agreed, says

"largest fraction" is what "plurality" means. however, once you do that you have to be specific about what your available categories are.

and "likely" turns out to be a weasel word. it doesn't really mean much.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://karalyg.myvidoop.com/

7 Kara needs a vacation who agreed, says

Not necessarily, Vynce.

plu·ral·i·ty Audio Help /plʊˈrælɪti/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[ploo-ral-i-tee] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–noun, plural -ties.
1. the excess of votes received by the leading candidate, in an election in which there are three or more candidates, over those received by the next candidate (distinguished from majority).
2. more than half of the whole; the majority.
3. a number greater than one.
4. fact of being numerous.
5. a large number; multitude.
6. state or fact of being plural.

And you might think likely is a weasel word, but it's not the way I use it, thank you very much. Take your pedantry elsewhere.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://vynce.myopenid.com/

8 Vynce who agreed, says

OK, then the way you use it is not the way it is always or maybe even generally used and you should have defined it in the claim description. Two of the common definitions are "probable" and "plausible" -- which are pretty different, in my opinion, so use without disambiguation is a bit weasely. In fact, Usage notes suggest that in formal writing one should not use it without quantifiers, as it is considered unclear.

But, to the point: if you mean "more than 50% likely" then, no, I don't think so. On the other hand, if you mean "largest fraction" then I still need to know what the other categories are in order to determine. If you are only dividing the site into 4 categories, based on sex & beer-drinking-ness, then, yes, probably that's the largest fraction. But if, for instance, you're dividing it into {males who drink beer} {females who do not drink beer} {either male or beer drinking but not both} then I am less sure.

(Thanks for the plurality of definitions; some of them I was not aware of, whereas others seemed not germaine to this conversation. I'm curious what your source was; neither Wikipedia, nor Wiktionary, nor Answers.com seem to quite agree, nor, I believe, does Robert's Rules of Order use the term differently than I describe it. You being a lawyer, I'd expect Robert's Rules to be familiar and pedantry to be de rigeur.)

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://darch.myopenid.com/

6 D'Archangel who agreed, says

"hmm, in my mind likely is either greater than half or the largest available fraction. "

That's "most likely".

"Take your pedantry elsewhere. "

Not only "no", but "hell, no".

D'A

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://logicaldog.myopenid.com/

4 Logical Dog who agreed, says

Kara: Take your pedantry elsewhere.

like: to a different claim, right, Kara?

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://claimid.com/dewe

6 DeWe who hasn't voted, says

dub

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://logicaldog.myopenid.com/

4 Logical Dog who agreed, says

pleasantly distractivating ...

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://xisth.information.myopenid.com/

4 Comestibles J Coolio who hasn't voted, says

dancehall stylee.

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://www.allentom.com/

5 Atom Dude who agreed, says

You might get a dog who drinks beer

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://logicaldog.myopenid.com/

4 Logical Dog who agreed, says

*slurppee slurp slurp*

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
http://xisth.information.myopenid.com/

4 Comestibles J Coolio who hasn't voted, says

are you two related?

Make a related claim 3 months ago (link)
Sign in in to leave a comment.