Every religion I am familiar with is based on lies.

By 8 Rorek on June 23, 2008

I'm not saying that there are no elements of truth in the teachings of religions, but that they are fundamentally based on fiction.

I weakened this claim from my original because I am not familiar enough with all the religions of the world, but I suspect it holds true for every religion.

Embed Claim Make a related claim

Discussion (10)

http://claimid.com/dewe

6 DeWe who hasn't voted, says

Lie implies an intent to mislead, be it white, black or grey; fiction ain't necessarily so.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://rorek.org/

8 Rorek who agreed, says

I'm aware. I think that usually religions are or were originally based on an intention to mislead. Perhaps I should have clarified that.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://rael.jandu.com.mx/

5 Rael who disagreed, says

I don't think so, there were for explaining why first. Then as people gave power to the gods (The sun, the rain) they start making their decisions based of superstitions as "A bright light inspire me to attack a community and conquer it" and then people used religion to take power of the masses. This is probably the phase that you are talking to.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://claimid.com/dewe

6 DeWe who hasn't voted, says

I think there's a bit of that, the rest is conjectural philosophising to make sense of the world.

I too am cynical when it comes to religion and believe the bases for religious doctrines were probably formulated by those with power, and that powerful people are likely, but not certainly, to be nasty fuckers.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
https://getopenid.com/sassen

3 Rolies who hasn't voted, says

Peoploids prefer to obey rather than think and be responsible for their own appelflappen.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://chron.myvidoop.com/

3 Chron who disagreed, says

No, and only for the reason that I consider calling something a lie an insult. Many (most?) great stories are fictions, but I wouldn't call them lies. Since I cannot know the original intent of the fictions underlying the various religions, I like to assume that they were just-so stories, understood to be false, but as a vehicle for other messages.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://mr.fye.oneandthesame.net/

3 SeƱor Surfer Smurf who hasn't voted, says

Chron, I like that take on it too but now it seems they aren't understood to be false.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://chron.myvidoop.com/

3 Chron who disagreed, says

Oh, I agree. But a lie is all about original intent.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://rach.myopenid.com/

10 Rachel who hasn't voted, says

Clearly your friends don't go around creating religions as often as mine do. They were not founded on lies. Sometimes on fiction, but not on lies.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
http://claimid.com/dewe

6 DeWe who hasn't voted, says

Then again, not necessarily on fiction, but on hearsay that was believed to be truth.

Make a related claim 5 months ago (link)
Sign in in to leave a comment.