1984 was a rather dumb book.

By 5 Unknown Entity on August 29, 2008

The book just didn't speak to me.

Embed Claim Make a related claim

Discussion (4)

http://mattspire.myopenid.com/

1 Matt Spire who disagreed, says

I think it should be read for what it is and not be over-interpreted; it's largely become a god-sized version of itself due to phrases like Orwellian entering our vocabulary.

I think it's a very relevant read, but many of the concepts in 1984 were not original to the book or Orwell. I do think it came at the right time, however, and said the right thing, to put words to and a face on resistance against totalitarian tactics as technology made many things possible that were not previously.

Make a related claim 2 months ago (link)
http://claimid.com/dewe

6 DeWe who hasn't voted, says

Try this.

Make a related claim 2 months ago (link)
http://claimid.com/dewe

6 DeWe who hasn't voted, says

I read 1983 first; it helped.

Make a related claim 2 months ago (link)
http://elihu.myopenid.com/

3 Elihu who disagreed, says

I don't think the book was universally awesome, but it wasn't bad either. I think 1984 suffers a little from its success; some people read it with very high expectations and are disappointed.

I recently read "Anthem", by Ayn Rand, and it seemed quite similar in many respects to 1984, and a pretty good book in general even though I don't agree with Rand on a lot of philosophical issues.

Make a related claim 2 months ago (link)
Sign in in to leave a comment.